Support and limitations
Exactly what is implemented, what is not, and which guarantees depend on you rather than on Ptah.
What is supported
Section titled “What is supported”| PostgreSQL | YDB, through its provider | Another provider engine | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Database | PostgreSQL with the pgvector extension | YDB, through its own vector functions and indexes, in the YDB provider’s embedding store | An engine whose executable provider keeps an embedding store |
| Provider API | OpenAI-compatible /v1/embeddings |
OpenAI-compatible /v1/embeddings |
OpenAI-compatible /v1/embeddings |
| Vector types | vector, halfvec, sparsevec |
float |
The provider’s |
| Metrics | cosine, l2, inner_product |
cosine, l2, inner_product |
cosine, l2, inner_product |
| Index methods | hnsw, ivfflat |
vector_kmeans_tree |
The provider’s |
| Consistency modes | outbox, immutable |
immutable |
The ones the engine declares; immutable today |
| Target layouts | source columns, own table | source columns, own table | source columns, own table |
The --db-url scheme decides the engine: a postgres:// URL, or a
keyword/value DSN with no scheme, is PostgreSQL, and a scheme an executable
provider serves, ydb:// and ydbs:// among them, is that provider’s engine. Every
verb runs the same lifecycle on each. The inference_plan and
inference_status tools of ptah mcp reach the same engines for the database
the operator configured.
A provider engine. A URL of an engine an installed official provider serves
selects that provider, and --provider-config or --provider-engine selects
one explicitly, as for every native command; see Test an executable
provider. Its engine has to declare the
embeddings.store feature, which contract 25.2 adds, and a provider without it
is refused by name. The provider keeps the run state in a layout of its own and
owns the vector storage, the index and the searches; Ptah keeps every
lifecycle decision and every refusal for a lifecycle reason. inference describe takes --provider-engine to describe the target objects of a
provider engine.
ptah mcp takes the same two flags beside --database-url, and its inference
tools then read the plan and the run state through the provider’s embedding
store. The operator names the provider when starting the server. No tool
argument names a manifest, an engine or an executable, and a call that adds one
is refused; see Configure agent
permissions.
YDB through its provider. A ydb:// or ydbs:// URL is served by the
provider that ptah providers install ydb installed, and inference needs a
provider release that keeps an embedding store. The provider keeps the run state
in row tables named ptah_embedding_* and stores each vector as the bytes YDB’s
float vector functions read; see
Embedding store.
What is not
Section titled “What is not”No other database engine. MySQL, SQLite, ClickHouse, SQL Server, Oracle and the rest are not supported, and a URL naming one is refused by name:
$ ptah inference plan --spec spec.yaml --db-url "mysql://localhost:3306/db"error: ptah inference works against PostgreSQL with pgvector and against aprovider engine with an embedding store, such as YDB, and "mysql://" namesanother engine: a generation's run state and its vectors need one of those, sothere is nothing here to run against mysqlThe PostgreSQL family is refused too. CockroachDB and YugabyteDB speak the wire protocol pgvector’s driver connects with and have no pgvector.
The inference_plan and inference_status tools of ptah mcp give the same
answers for a configured target, before they connect to it.
No outbox on YDB. The outbox records each source change with a row trigger
in the transaction that makes it, and YDB has no triggers. The YDB provider
declares immutable as its only consistency mode, so plan reports outbox
as a blocker and prepare refuses it before anything is created, naming the
mode the engine declares.
A YDB source that can change is migrated as a paused source; see Migrate a paused source.
On YDB the key is the primary key. source.key_fields has to name the
source table’s primary key, in key order. A YDB table keeps its rows in
primary-key order, so the keyset scan is a range read and a write addresses one
row; any other key would make each page a full read. A specification naming
other columns is refused with the key the table has.
A YDB vector index needs a line that has one. YDB 25.1 builds a
vector_kmeans_tree index only with its EnableVectorIndex feature flag on.
index refuses on a server whose capabilities have no vector_indexes, and
reads the cluster’s flags when the URL names its monitoring endpoint.
On YDB 25.1 and 25.2 an indexed generation takes no more writes. The vector
index on those lines answers as it stood at its build, while the table moves
on. A write into a generation whose index exists is refused there, naming the
capability, vector_index_maintained_on_write, and the line; YDB 25.3 and later
take the write into the index. Build the index after the backfill, as the
lifecycle does, and the refusal is reached only when a source the specification
declares immutable has changed.
No cascade on a YDB table of the generation’s own. YDB has no foreign keys, so deleting a source row does not delete its vectors. Verification reports such a row as outside the generation’s source scope.
No other provider API. A provider that is not OpenAI-compatible needs a gateway in front of it.
One set of chunks per source row, in a table of its own. A row split into
several vectors needs layout: own_table; see Choose a target
layout.
No change-data-capture connectors. The outbox is triggers on your PostgreSQL table. There is no logical-replication, YDB changefeed or CDC-tool integration.
No Kubernetes operator. Nothing reconciles a generation change from a custom
resource. The verbs run as Jobs and a rollout gates on
status --require-ready; see Run in Kubernetes.
Ptah is not an inference server. It does not run a model, hold one in memory, schedule a GPU, store model weights, or answer a search query.
Guarantees that are Ptah’s
Section titled “Guarantees that are Ptah’s”- A change that committed to the source has an outbox event, under
outbox, because the event and the change are one transaction — and catch-up reads every one of those events. Its cursor is a transaction identity and a sequence together, so a page that fills partway through a transaction resumes inside that transaction rather than past it. - A vector and its checkpoint are written in one transaction, so there is no state in which the work landed and the record of it did not. On a provider engine, YDB included, it is one atomic compare-and-write in the provider; a commit whose state changed after it was read writes nothing, and Ptah reads and decides again.
- A write never crosses generations: a row belonging to another generation is refused rather than overwritten.
- A stale result does not win. A provider answer computed from a source version the row has moved past is discarded rather than written.
- A deleted row stays deleted: a tombstone survives an embedding that was already in flight.
- A worker whose lease was taken cannot commit, because the fencing token is checked in the write itself rather than read and then trusted.
- A cutover binds to a plan digest, and what is true now is checked again at the moment it runs.
Guarantees that are yours
Section titled “Guarantees that are yours”- That the source is what you said it is.
mutable: falseis a declaration Ptah takes and measures afterwards; it cannot stop a write. - That the model is stable. If the provider exposes no immutable revision,
planreports the reproducibility as partial and names the reason. It cannot detect a model that changed under a stable name. - That your queries read the active generation. Ptah moves a pointer in its own tables. Your application’s SQL names a column, and connecting the two is yours.
- That the query vector comes from the same model. A query embedded by a different model is not comparable with the stored vectors, and nothing errors.
- That the metric and the operator match.
<=>for cosine,<->for l2,<#>for inner product. A mismatch returns the wrong rows in a plausible order. - That the results are good. Verification measures shape, coverage and
freshness. Quality is
evaluate, against a corpus you write.
What Ptah cannot see
Section titled “What Ptah cannot see”- A change made by a path that bypasses the source table’s triggers —
COPYwith triggers disabled, a replication apply, a direct catalog edit. - A provider that logs or retains your inputs.
- Whether the columns you chose for
input_fieldsare the right ones.
Known operational costs
Section titled “Known operational costs”- Two triggers and one companion-table insert per changed row, under
outbox, for the length of the migration. - On a provider engine, a lifecycle decision is two calls, a read and a compare-and-write, and so is a batch commit. A decision over the whole run state conflicts with every concurrent batch commit and is decided again.
- Five columns on the target table per generation, and two generations coexist by design.
- The provider bill for the whole corpus, per generation.
- A vector index build that is concurrent but not free.
Version
Section titled “Version”The limits above describe the checked build. Any unavailable inference behavior is marked at the sentence that names it.